# Board of Supervisors Minutes: April 13, 2010

- Meeting date: 2010-04-13
- Document type: minutes
- Source format: PDF
- Extracted pages: 23
- [Canonical HTML transcript](https://sfbos.info/documents/1990/2010-04-13-minutes)
- [Authoritative City source](https://sfbos.archive.sf.gov/ftp/meetingarchive/full_board/ftp/uploadedfiles/bdsupvrs/bosagendas/minutes/2010/m041310.pdf)

> This text was extracted for search and accessibility. The linked City source is the authoritative public record.

## Structured legislative records

### File 100288: Public Hearing - Appeal of Determination of Statutory Exemption from Environmental Review for San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency Transit Service Reductions and Related Fiscal Emergency

- Pages: 10-11

### File 100289: Affirming the Statutory Exemption Determination for the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency Fiscal Emergency

- Pages: 11
- Vote 1: tabling
  - Action: 100289 [Affirming the Statutory Exemption Determination for the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency Fiscal Emergency] Motion affirming the determination by the Planning Department that the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency decision to implement service reductions is statutorily exempt from environmental review. Supervisor Campos, seconded by Supervisor Daly, moved that this Motion be TABLED. The motion FAILED by the following vote:
  - Ayes: Avalos, Campos, Daly, Mar
  - Noes: Alioto-Pier, Chiu, Chu, Dufty, Elsbernd, Maxwell, Mirkarimi
- Vote 2: approval, likely final
  - Action: Supervisor Chu, seconded by Supervisor Dufty, moved that this Motion be APPROVED. The motion carried by the following vote:
  - Ayes: Alioto-Pier, Chiu, Chu, Dufty, Elsbernd, Maxwell
  - Noes: Avalos, Campos, Daly, Mar, Mirkarimi

### File 100290: Reversing the Statutory Exemption Determination for the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency Service Reductions

- Pages: 11
- Vote 1: approval, likely final
  - Action: 100290 [Reversing the Statutory Exemption Determination for the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency Service Reductions] Motion reversing the determination by the Planning Department that the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency decision to implement service reductions is statutorily exempt from environmental review. (Clerk of the Board) Supervisor Campos, seconded by Supervisor Daly, moved that this Motion be APPROVED. The motion FAILED by the following vote:
  - Ayes: Avalos, Campos, Daly, Mar
  - Noes: Alioto-Pier, Chiu, Chu, Dufty, Elsbernd, Maxwell, Mirkarimi
- Vote 2: tabling
  - Action: Supervisor Chu, seconded by Supervisor Dufty, moved that this Motion be TABLED. The motion carried by the following vote:
  - Ayes: Alioto-Pier, Chiu, Chu, Dufty, Elsbernd, Maxwell
  - Noes: Avalos, Campos, Daly, Mar, Mirkarimi

### File 100291: Preparation of Findings Related to the Exemption Determination for the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency Service Reductions

- Pages: 11
- Vote 1: approval, likely final
  - Action: 100291 [Preparation of Findings Related to the Exemption Determination for the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency Service Reductions] Motion directing the Clerk of the Board to prepare findings related to the appeal of the exemption determination by the Planning Department that the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency decision to implement service reductions is exempt from environmental review. (Clerk of the Board) Supervisor Campos, seconded by Supervisor Daly, moved that this Motion be APPROVED. The motion FAILED by the following vote:
  - Ayes: Avalos, Campos, Daly, Mar
  - Noes: Alioto-Pier, Chiu, Chu, Dufty, Elsbernd, Maxwell, Mirkarimi
- Vote 2: tabling
  - Action: Supervisor Chu, seconded by Supervisor Dufty, moved that this Motion be TABLED. The motion carried by the following vote:
  - Ayes: Alioto-Pier, Chiu, Chu, Dufty, Elsbernd, Maxwell
  - Noes: Avalos, Campos, Daly, Mar, Mirkarimi

## Extracted text

### [Page 11](https://sfbos.info/documents/1990/2010-04-13-minutes#page-11)

Board of Supervisors Meeting Minutes - Final Tuesday, April 13, 2010

100289 [Affirming the Statutory Exemption Determination for the San Francisco Municipal
 Transportation Agency Fiscal Emergency]
 Motion affirming the determination by the Planning Department that the San Francisco Municipal
 Transportation Agency decision to implement service reductions is statutorily exempt from
 environmental review.
 Supervisor Campos, seconded by Supervisor Daly, moved that this Motion be TABLED. The
 motion FAILED by the following vote:
 Ayes: 4 - Avalos, Campos, Daly, Mar
 Noes: 7 - Alioto-Pier, Chiu, Chu, Dufty, Elsbernd, Maxwell, Mirkarimi
 Supervisor Chu, seconded by Supervisor Dufty, moved that this Motion be APPROVED. The motion
 carried by the following vote:
 Ayes: 6 - Alioto-Pier, Chiu, Chu, Dufty, Elsbernd, Maxwell
 Noes: 5 - Avalos, Campos, Daly, Mar, Mirkarimi

100290 [Reversing the Statutory Exemption Determination for the San Francisco Municipal
 Transportation Agency Service Reductions]
 Motion reversing the determination by the Planning Department that the San Francisco Municipal
 Transportation Agency decision to implement service reductions is statutorily exempt from
 environmental review. (Clerk of the Board)
 Supervisor Campos, seconded by Supervisor Daly, moved that this Motion be APPROVED. The
 motion FAILED by the following vote:
 Ayes: 4 - Avalos, Campos, Daly, Mar
 Noes: 7 - Alioto-Pier, Chiu, Chu, Dufty, Elsbernd, Maxwell, Mirkarimi
 Supervisor Chu, seconded by Supervisor Dufty, moved that this Motion be TABLED. The motion
 carried by the following vote:
 Ayes: 6 - Alioto-Pier, Chiu, Chu, Dufty, Elsbernd, Maxwell
 Noes: 5 - Avalos, Campos, Daly, Mar, Mirkarimi

100291 [Preparation of Findings Related to the Exemption Determination for the San
 Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency Service Reductions]
 Motion directing the Clerk of the Board to prepare findings related to the appeal of the exemption
 determination by the Planning Department that the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency
 decision to implement service reductions is exempt from environmental review. (Clerk of the
 Board)
 Supervisor Campos, seconded by Supervisor Daly, moved that this Motion be APPROVED. The
 motion FAILED by the following vote:
 Ayes: 4 - Avalos, Campos, Daly, Mar
 Noes: 7 - Alioto-Pier, Chiu, Chu, Dufty, Elsbernd, Maxwell, Mirkarimi
 Supervisor Chu, seconded by Supervisor Dufty, moved that this Motion be TABLED. The motion
 carried by the following vote:
 Ayes: 6 - Alioto-Pier, Chiu, Chu, Dufty, Elsbernd, Maxwell
 Noes: 5 - Avalos, Campos, Daly, Mar, Mirkarimi

ROLL CALL FOR INTRODUCTIONS
 See Legislation Introduced below.

City and County of San Francisco Page 315 Printed at 4:42 pm on 5/12/10